Skip to content
MMA Calendar

UFC & MMA BlogInvestigations

Damage vs control in UFC judging: what 11,085 scored rounds show

Do UFC judges reward damage or control? I matched 11,085 scored rounds to round stats. Three minutes on top with almost no strikes still wins 9 in 10.

By Mate BersenadzePublished: Read time: 10 min read

Kyoji Horiguchi

On Saturday at UFC Qatar, Asu Almabayev held Kyoji Horiguchi down for 4:34 of the second round and 3:52 of the third, and lost both rounds on most cards. On the same card, Aljamain Sterling controlled Kevin Vallejos for 1:59 of the last round, was out-landed 15 to 8 in significant strikes, and lost that round on all three cards. I went through those cards round by round in the scorecards piece, so I won't repeat them here.

The reaction to the first one was close to a celebration. The idea was that judges have finally started scoring damage over control. That argument has been around as long as wrestlers have been winning decisions, but it comes up more than twice as often after UFC cards now as it did before 2022. Fans clearly think something changed.

So I checked. We hold the judges' round-by-round cards and the official round stats for thousands of UFC decisions. If judges had moved toward damage, it would show up in the rounds where one fighter wins the control and the other wins the striking.

It doesn't. On average they haven't moved at all, and the one corner of the data that did move went the other way.

How I measured it

Let's get the definitions out of the way first, because the whole argument depends on them.

The sample. Every UFC bout since 2010 that went to a decision, where we hold both the official per-round stats and each judge's round-by-round card. That is 3,515 fights, 11,085 rounds and 32,685 individual judge scores. Fights that ended inside the distance are left out.

Control winner. The fighter with at least one minute more control time in the round. I used the standard per-round control time from the official stats. Later I also use position-tracking data that splits control into clinch and ground, but the headline numbers use the standard figure.

Damage winner. The fighter who scored more knockdowns. If knockdowns were level, the fighter who landed more significant strikes. This is the weak spot, and I'll say so now: a significant strike is a volume count. A jab and a head kick each count as one. Apart from knockdowns, no per-round stat measures damage. Strike count is the closest thing we have.

Split round. A round where the control winner and the damage winner are different people. There are 1,828 of them, 16.5 percent of all rounds in the sample, and they carry 5,400 judge scores. These are the rounds the debate is about, and judges find them hard. All three judges agreed on 68.4 percent of split rounds, against 79.7 percent of every other round.

Lay round. The extreme case: a fighter with at least three minutes more control who landed five significant strikes or fewer and scored no knockdown. There are 402 of them.

The answer by year

Kyoji Horiguchi

Photo: Bruno Massami / CC BY 3.0

Across all 1,828 split rounds, 46.5 percent of judge scores went to the damage side and 53.1 percent to the control side. The rest were 10-10s. Here is how that looks year by year, next to how often the fighter on top won a lay round:

YearSplit roundsScores to damage sideLay roundsLay rounds won by the controller
2010-201656844.7%12887.0%
20179459.9%1286.1%
20189652.4%1190.6%
201912547.0%2091.7%
202012146.8%1980.7%
202113845.9%2990.8%
202212742.0%3593.3%
202312543.2%2592.0%
202416449.0%3497.1%
202513950.4%4389.9%
202613141.0%4689.1%

2026 runs through UFC Qatar on November 21. Percentages are shares of individual judge scores.

There is one bump. In 2017 the damage side took 59.9 percent of scores, and by 2019 it was back in the forties, where it has stayed. Grouped into eras, the damage side got 44.7 percent of scores from 2010 to 2016, 49.6 percent from 2017 to 2021 and 45.4 percent from 2022 to 2026.

You could object that the mix of rounds changed over time, with bigger or smaller margins in some years. So I checked that too. I took the rate at which each combination of control margin and strike margin goes to the damage side, and asked how each era did against it. The answer was 2.0 points below expectation for 2010 to 2016, 2.4 above for 2017 to 2021 and 0.4 below for 2022 to 2026. That is the same judging, era after era.

The lay rounds column is the one the debate should be looking at. A fighter who holds the other man down for three minutes and lands next to nothing won 87.0 percent of judge scores from 2010 to 2016 and 92.0 percent from 2022 to 2026. They also made up a bigger share of rounds recently: 3.6 percent from 2010 to 2016, 2.5 percent from 2017 to 2021 and 4.6 percent from 2022 to 2026. In the bigger version of that bucket, every split round with three minutes or more of control, the controller took 76.2 percent of scores from 2010 to 2016 (108 rounds) and 85.8 percent from 2022 to 2026 (157 rounds).

I wouldn't claim judges have moved toward control on that evidence. A gap of that size on samples that small is about two standard errors, which is suggestive and not proof. What the data rules out is the story that judges have moved toward damage.

The exchange rate

The most useful thing in this data is not the trend. It's the price. Judges behave as if a minute of control is worth a certain number of significant strikes, and the rate is consistent enough to put in a table.

Share of judge scores that went to the fighter who landed more significant strikes, in split rounds with no knockdown, 2010 to 2026 (rounds in brackets):

Control marginOut-landed by 1-45-910-1920+
1:00-1:5939.9% (274)55.4% (289)79.9% (224)97.2% (59)
2:00-2:5924.2% (203)41.4% (167)63.2% (114)81.1% (25)
3:00+8.1% (236)23.9% (97)55.9% (43)100% (7)

Read along a row to find where the striker becomes the favorite. With one to two minutes of control against him, he needs about five more significant strikes. Against two to three minutes, he needs about ten. Against three minutes or more, even ten to nineteen more significant strikes only gets him a coin flip. Roughly, a minute of control buys five significant strikes, and more than that in long top-position rounds.

That is the honest version of "control over damage." Judges don't ignore strikes. They price control highly, and a striker who wins by a handful of significant strikes loses the round most of the time.

The 2017 to 2021 era looks gentler here too. At two to three minutes of control, the damage side took 49.9 percent of scores in that era, against 35.4 percent from 2022 to 2026.

Knockdowns change the price. A knockdown beat a one-to-two-minute control edge in 79.2 percent of scores (44 rounds) and a two-to-three-minute edge in 62.9 percent (33 rounds). Against three minutes or more there are only 13 such rounds, which is too few to say anything.

The rulebook says damage first

The rules side of the argument is simple. In 2025 the Association of Boxing Commissions' MMA rules committee published a judging criteria clarification, dated July 2025. It says:

Damage is the most highly valued component in judging a round

On grappling, it says that "merely holding a dominant position(s) shall not be considered demonstrating dominance in a round."

That is about as clear as a rules document gets, and it is the exact case the debate is about. So I split the recent rounds at August 2025. From January 2022 to July 2025, the damage side took 45.9 percent of split-round scores (498 rounds). From August 2025 to UFC Qatar it took 44.0 percent (188 rounds). Lay rounds were won by the controller in 93.2 percent of scores before (118 rounds) and 89.7 percent after (65 rounds).

The scorecards I can see don't show the clarification yet. I can't tell from scorecards whether every commission working UFC events has adopted it, and 65 lay rounds is a small sample. But for now there is no shift.

Clinch control is not ground control

Asu Almabayev

Photo: Qazaq Stand Up / CC BY 4.0

Control time adds up two very different things: pinning a man against the fence and holding him on the mat. Our position-tracking data separates them for 11,079 of the 11,085 rounds. When I rebuild the split rounds with a margin of two minutes or more in one kind of control, and the controller was out-landed, the difference is large.

When the controller was out-landed by 1 to 4 significant strikes, he won 88.3 percent of scores with a ground control edge (302 rounds), against 62.5 percent with a clinch control edge (84 rounds). Out-landed by 5 to 9, the figures are 69.4 percent (146 rounds) against 44.6 percent (64). Out-landed by 10 to 19, they are 48.4 percent (64) against 28.4 percent (61).

So judges are not scoring control time as a single thing. Holding a man against the fence is worth much less than holding him on the mat. When fans complain about control, they usually picture ground control, and ground control is the kind that keeps winning.

What actually beats the man on top

Here is the case Saturday made. In the 402 lay rounds, I split the rounds by total strikes, which include the short shots from guard that rarely count as significant:

  • If the controller was level or ahead in total strikes, he won 96.2 percent of scores (274 rounds).
  • If the fighter underneath out-landed him in total strikes by 1 to 19, the controller won 83.1 percent (88 rounds).
  • If the fighter underneath out-landed him by 20 or more, the controller won only 59.2 percent (40 rounds).

Those last 40 rounds are where Horiguchi won his fight. In round 2, Almabayev held him for 4:34 and landed no significant strikes. Horiguchi landed 4 significant strikes and 53 total strikes to Almabayev's 7. In round 3, total strikes ran 87 to 9. Rounds with that control and that significant-strike count went to the man on the bottom in 8.1 and 23.9 percent of scores. Out of six scores across those two rounds, Horiguchi took five.

Since 2010, only 40 of the 402 lay rounds were lost by the controller on two or more cards. Almabayev accounts for two of them, from a single night.

Sterling is a smaller case. His third round falls in the 1:00-1:59 control, 5-9 strike row of the table, where the damage side wins 55.4 percent of scores. All three judges going to Vallejos was the slightly more likely outcome. The fight drew so much argument because the round was so close to the line, not because the judging was new.

Joshua Van's win over Alexandre Pantoja despite 9:11 of control had the same shape. Control loses when the other man keeps landing, and landing a lot. It does not lose because judges have changed their view of control.

Where that leaves the debate

Fans are right about the rulebook, which now says damage first in plain words. They are wrong about the scorecards. Across 32,685 judge scores, a fighter who wins the control and loses the striking is scored the same way he was in 2014. Three minutes on top with almost nothing landed won about nine times in ten, then and now.

UFC Qatar didn't show judges changing. It showed what it takes to beat the existing scoring from the bottom: 53 and 87 total strikes in rounds where the other man landed 7 and 9. Most fighters stuck underneath for four and a half minutes won't land anything like that. If the clarification is meant to change how those rounds are scored, the next 400 lay rounds will show it.

More from the blog

  1. Nov 21, 2026UFC Qatar scorecards: the one judge who had Topuria, and how Sterling lost the close rounds
  2. Nov 21, 2026UFC Qatar results: Navajo Stirling knocks out Jiri Prochazka at 4:58 of round 2
  3. Nov 21, 2026Projected UFC rankings after UFC Qatar: Stirling to No. 2, Vallejos to No. 4
  4. Nov 16, 2026UFC Qatar rankings stakes: what Prochazka vs Stirling and five more fights do to the board
  5. Nov 16, 2026Sterling vs Vallejos odds and prediction: UFC Qatar makes the former champion a 45 percent underdog
Add UFCalendar as a preferred source on GoogleOur fight-week coverage shows up first in your Top stories.
Ask UFCalendar AI